An honest, side-by-side comparison to help Florida lead buyers choose the right platform for their vertical and use case.
EverQuote is a consumer insurance marketplace — it operates comparison tools that help consumers compare quotes across carriers. EverQuote sells leads to insurance agents and carriers primarily through their own consumer-facing properties. They operate across all 50 states and offer both auto and home insurance leads.
| Feature | Dreamy Leads | EverQuote |
|---|---|---|
| Lead source | Owned SEO pages targeting FL consumers | EverQuote consumer marketplace |
| Exclusivity | Exclusive — one buyer per lead | Shared leads available; exclusive at premium |
| Verticals | Insurance, Mortgage, Solar, Debt Relief | Insurance primary (auto, home, life, health) |
| Geographic focus | Florida-only, 16 specific markets | National — all 50 states |
| TCPA consent | Uniform consent per lead, fully documented | Documented; EverQuote manages consent |
| Quality scoring | Proprietary 14-signal pre-auction score | Proprietary scoring within their marketplace |
| CPL range (insurance) | $8–$28 typical | $15–$45+ depending on coverage type |
| Minimum commitment | No minimum | May require minimum monthly spend |
| Non-insurance leads | Mortgage, Solar, Debt Relief available | Insurance only |
EverQuote is the right choice for insurance-only buyers who need national scale, want to buy from a large established marketplace, or are primarily focused on auto and home in states outside Florida.
Dreamy Leads is the right choice for Florida-focused buyers who want exclusive leads across multiple verticals, consistent TCPA documentation on every lead, and the ability to add mortgage, solar, or debt leads to the same buyer account without managing multiple vendor relationships.
Applications take 5 minutes. Most buyers go live within 24 hours. No platform fee, no monthly minimum — pay only for leads you accept.
Apply for API Access →